What makes training dogs different from training dolphins or other animals?
What makes training dogs different from training humans?
We're all trainable because we all like food, right?
I suspect that what makes dogs different from humans is less substantial than the difference between dogs and dolphins. Why? Dogs and humans have a special cross-species relationship because they understand each other, or have the ability to easily learn to do so.
What facilitates this learning? Shared practice of communication via body language, shared motivators, shared social structure. (Well, human MEN naturally form and accept social hierarchies. WOMEN do not form, accept, or even recognize social hierarchies.) Dogs & humans enjoy some level of cooperative interaction and some level of independent decision-making. We are both novelty-seeking, but unsettled by novelty overload. We share similar emotional ranges, even if only humans think & feel about their emotions. We have amazing problem-solving capabilities when presented with a completely new challenge or opportunity. We both accept a market economy-- where value is affected by the reactions of others. Even our "unwanted" behaviors are oddly similar -- destruction, depression, rage, violence, rudeness, quivering, anti-social.
It's possible that, being human, we can only notice behaviors that have meaning to humans. I'm skeptical of deliberate pheromone communication, but that may be only because I have no ability to deliberately release pheromones.
Of course, I haven't worked with dolphins. Maybe this post is just a big excuse for me to find a way to train dolphins. =)
Thoughts and observations from someone who has been repeatedly introduced as "Nicole Silvers, that dog whisperer lady I was telling you about" I don't whisper to dogs; I eavesdrop on their conversations with each other.
Search This Blog
Blog Archive
-
►
2014
(1)
- ► January 2014 (1)
-
►
2010
(14)
- ► March 2010 (4)
- ► February 2010 (9)
- ► January 2010 (1)
-
▼
2009
(88)
- ► November 2009 (4)
- ► October 2009 (4)
- ► September 2009 (3)
- ► August 2009 (11)
-
▼
July 2009
(32)
- Invisible Fences are NOT COOL
- Monash Canine Personality Questionnaire
- Isn't that Pain? -- REdefining Punishment
- Elicitation-- Step 2 -- Getting the Dog to Do It
- DIY Dog Training
- Correction does not equal Learning
- Thinking & Feeling
- Cotton --Canine Disarming?
- Large Dog, Glass Sliding Door
- BOYCOTT Lancaster County Products
- The Rescue Business
- Recall = "Come" Command
- You're Going To Do What I Say.... Or You're Going...
- I will not tolerate your crap
- Effects of Stress on (Human) Cognition
- Puppyhood--Keep The Faith
- Guest Post on ILRA
- Hungarian study of 14,000 -- Dog and owner demogra...
- Thoughts inspired by recent study-- "Dyadic relati...
- Dog Training and Dan Ariely's "Predictably Irratio...
- Help Your Dog Always Have the Right Answer
- Training Dogs Vs Training Dolphins or any other sp...
- That's Treats, Right? -- Defining "Rewards"
- More on Cesar Millan
- Jumping Thru Hoops
- Manipulation for Wives & Pet Owners
- My Dominant Houseplant
- The Dog is Biting
- The Rescue Rant
- It's HERE! It's HERE!
- Impenetrable Fingers or How Not to Meet a Dog
- Overview of Basic Approaches to Problem-Solving
Friday, July 10, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment